Cosmic Chocolate Pralines: Physicists’ Surprising Discovery About Neutron Star Structure
Through extensive model calculations, physicists at Goethe University Frankfurt have reached general conclusions about the internal structure of neutron stars, where matter reaches enormous densities: depending on their mass, the stars can have a core that is either very stiff or very soft. The findings were published simultaneously in two articles.
Neutron stars are extremely compact objects that can form after the death of a star. They have the mass of our sun or even more, but are incredibly compressed into a sphere with the diameter of a large city. Since their discovery more than 60 years ago, scientists have been trying to decipher their structure. Thus far, however, little is known about the interior of neutron stars.
As their extreme properties prevent them from being recreated on Earth in the laboratory, the greatest challenge is to simulate the extreme conditions inside neutron stars. There are therefore many models in which various properties – from density and temperature – are described with the help of so-called equations of state. These equations attempt to describe the structure of neutron stars from the stellar surface to the inner core.
Now physicists at Goethe University Frankfurt have succeeded in adding further crucial pieces to the puzzle. The working group led by Prof. Luciano Rezzolla at the Institute of Theoretical Physics developed more than a million different equations of state that satisfy the constraints set by data obtained from theoretical nuclear physics on the one hand, and by astronomical observations on the other.
When evaluating the equations of state, the working group made a surprising discovery: “Light” neutron stars (with masses smaller than about 1.7 solar masses) seem to have a soft mantle and a stiff core, whereas “heavy” neutron stars (with masses larger than 1.7 solar masses) instead have a stiff mantle and a soft core.
“This result is very interesting because it gives us a direct measure of how compressible the center of neutron stars can be,” says Prof. Luciano Rezzolla, “Neutron stars apparently behave a bit like chocolate pralines: light stars resemble those chocolates that have a hazelnut in their center surrounded by soft chocolate, whereas heavy stars can be considered more like those chocolates where a hard layer contains a soft filling.”
Crucial to this insight was the speed of sound, a study focus of Bachelor’s student Sinan Altiparmak. This quantity measure describes how fast sound waves propagate within an object and depends on how stiff or soft matter is. Here on Earth, the speed of sound is used to explore the interior of the planet and discover oil deposits.
By modeling the equations of state, the physicists were also able to uncover other previously unexplained properties of neutron stars. For example, regardless of their mass, they very probably have a radius of only 12 km (7 miles). Thus, they are just as large in diameter as Goethe University’s hometown Frankfurt.
Author Dr. Christian Ecker explains: “Our extensive numerical study not only allows us to make predictions for the radii and maximum masses of neutron stars, but also to set new limits on their deformability in binary systems, that is, how strongly they distort each other through their gravitational fields. These insights will become particularly important to pinpoint the unknown equation of state with future astronomical observations and detections of gravitational waves from merging stars.”
So, while the exact structure and composition of matter inside neutron stars continue to remain a mystery, the wait until its discovery can certainly be sweetened with a chocolate or two.
“On the Sound Speed in Neutron Stars” by Sinan Altiparmak, Christian Ecker and Luciano Rezzolla, 10 November 2022, The Astrophysical Journal Letters.
“A General, Scale-independent Description of the Sound Speed in Neutron Stars” by Christian Ecker and Luciano Rezzolla, 10 November 2022, The Astrophysical Journal Letters.