As Marvel’s epics get bigger, Black Widow’s stakes feel too small

Black Widow was launched on the flawed time, in a number of methods. The brand new Marvel prequel was probably the most high-profile movies to be displaced by the continuously shifting theatrical launch schedule brought on by the shuttering of theaters because of the COVID-19 pandemic. However Black Widow — a movie set between Captain America: Civil Warfare’s superhero dust-up and Avengers: Infinity Warfare’s cosmos-spanning epic — appears like a film that ought to have been launched when it’s really set, as a substitute of as a belated prequel.

Warning: spoilers forward for Black Widow, Avengers: Endgame, Loki, and the final Marvel Cinematic Universe

It’s not that Black Widow is a foul film or an unworthy member of the Marvel saga. Its model of James Bond-esque spy-fi harks again to a few of the extra grounded MCU movies like Captain America: The Winter Soldier, much less targeted on superpowered smack-downs in favor of extra conventional motion film fare.

And if it had been launched in 2016 after Civil Warfare, that may have been high-quality. However Marvel’s movies have undergone huge shifts in tone since then. Physician Unusual opened up the related universe to straight-up magic, Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 and Thor: Ragnarok each supplied galaxy-spanning adventures with entire planets at stake, and naturally, Infinity Warfare and Endgame see the Avengers — and Natasha Romanov — battle to avoid wasting fairly actually all of existence.

In any case that, Black Widow’s stakes feel low, particularly for a personality that followers have gotten to see in motion in far greater adventures for over a decade. For all of the joking about how Thor might deal with the Purple Room with out breaking a sweat, the over-the-top actuality that’s the common day-to-day of the fashionable Marvel exhibits and films hangs over Black Widow’s throwback fashion.

Nothing in Black Widow’s story actually necessitates it to be a prequel, both. Positive, it’s enjoyable to see the place Natasha will get her Infinity Warfare get-up from. However exterior of its post-credit setup (which is about within the MCU’s post-Endgame “current”), there’s no story factor or revelation about Natasha’s character that may be completely different had the movie been launched a half-decade earlier.

In reality, understanding Natasha has this discovered household to guard (one which the remainder of the Avengers didn’t learn about) might have arguably deepened her short-shrifted sacrifice in Endgame. Think about if Natasha’s adopted sister or dad and mom have been misplaced in Thanos’ snap, and the sequence the place she fights with Hawkeye over who will get to fling themselves off a cliff has the added weight of making an attempt to carry them again, too. (As a substitute, we had Clint as the one one to probably should sacrifice being together with his household.)

Distinction that with Loki. The present is airing on Disney Plus proper as Black Widow comes out, and it additionally examines an older model of a Marvel character in a brand new gentle. However the place Loki is utilizing that perspective to re-examine what makes its titular character tick, and what separates the model of Loki then from the extra heroic one followers have been acquainted with, Black Widow doesn’t give Natasha the possibility to vary or develop. She’s already on the finish of her journey, absolutely shaped — she’s simply the one one who doesn’t realize it.

Black Widow additionally suffers from COVID-related delays; Disney is barely releasing it now as a result of it’s operating out of time, thematically. Its interconnected internet of exhibits and films implies that Marvel can’t advance with collection like Hawkeye (which is able to instantly observe up Black Widow’s post-credits scene). However it additionally implies that Black Widow’s comparatively grounded and reasonable journey is coming after WandaVision’s sorcerous saga or Lokis era-spanning epic.

It’s not that Black Widow doesn’t attempt to increase the stakes, establishing Dreykov’s military of Widows as some type of large, political power that secretly controls the world. However when you get cosmic magical house mysteries because the norm, it’s exhausting to return to “spies, however higher” as your desk stakes.

There’s a world the place Marvel was prepared to decide to a movie led by one among its feminine characters in 2016 as a substitute of 2019 (when Captain Marvel lastly broke the MCU’s decade-long streak of male protagonists), the place Black Widow serves as a highlight on Natasha’s origins forward of her final sacrifice, and the place the stakes are nonetheless aligned with the studio’s different properties.

Based mostly on the trailer for Marvel’s subsequent theatrical bow, Shang-Chi is about to punch a dragon within the face with magic house rings. And subsequent to that, it’s exhausting to not feel like Black Widow’s model of extra grounded spy motion is too little, too late.

Back to top button