Science & Technology

Geophysicist’s “Mind-Blowing” Discovery: Plato Was Right – Earth Is Made, on Average, of Cubes

The traditional thinker Plato conjectured that the universe was composed of explicit geometric shapes; the earth, of cubes. Findings from a multidisciplinary analysis workforce discovered reality in Plato’s perception.

The traditional Greek thinker was on to one thing, researchers discovered.

Plato, the Greek thinker who lived within the fifth century B.C.E., believed that the universe was made of 5 sorts of matter: earth, air, hearth, water, and cosmos. Every was described with a selected geometry, a platonic form. For earth, that form was the dice.

Science has steadily moved past Plato’s conjectures, trying as a substitute to the atom because the constructing block of the universe. But Plato appears to have been onto one thing, researchers have discovered.

“It seems that Plato’s conception concerning the aspect earth being made up of cubes is, actually, the statistical common mannequin for actual earth. And that’s simply mind-blowing.” — Douglas Jerolmack

In a brand new paper within the Proceedings of the Nationwide Academy of Sciences, a workforce from the College of Pennsylvania, Budapest College of Know-how and Economics, and College of Debrecen makes use of math, geology, and physics to show that the typical form of rocks on Earth is a dice. 

“Plato is well known as the primary individual to develop the idea of an atom, the concept matter consists of some indivisible part on the smallest scale,” says Douglas Jerolmack, a geophysicist in Penn’s Faculty of Arts & Sciences’ Division of Earth and Environmental Science and within the Faculty of Engineering and Utilized Sciences’ Division of Mechanical Engineering and Utilized Mechanics. “However that understanding was solely conceptual; nothing about our trendy understanding of atoms derives from what Plato advised us. 

“The attention-grabbing factor right here is that what we discover with rock, or earth, is that there’s greater than a conceptual lineage again to Plato. It seems that Plato’s conception concerning the aspect earth being made up of cubes is, actually, the statistical common mannequin for actual earth. And that’s simply mind-blowing.”

The group’s discovering started with geometric fashions developed by mathematician Gábor Domokos of the Budapest College of Know-how and Economics, whose work predicted that pure rocks would fragment into cubic shapes. 

“This paper is the outcome of three years of critical pondering and work, nevertheless it comes again to 1 core concept,” says Domokos. “If you happen to take a three-dimensional polyhedral form, slice it randomly into two fragments after which slice these fragments time and again, you get an unlimited quantity of completely different polyhedral shapes. However in a median sense, the ensuing form of the fragments is a dice.”

The analysis workforce measured and analyzed fragmentation patterns of rocks they collected in addition to from beforehand assembled datasets. Credit score: Courtesy of Gablor Domokos and Douglas Jerolmack

Domokos pulled two Hungarian theoretical physicists into the loop: Ferenc Kun, an knowledgeable on fragmentation, and János Török, an knowledgeable on statistical and computational fashions. After discussing the potential of the invention, Jerolmack says, the Hungarian researchers took their discovering to Jerolmack to work collectively on the geophysical questions; in different phrases, “How does nature let this occur?”

“After we took this to Doug, he mentioned, ‘That is both a mistake, or that is large,’” Domokos recollects. “We labored backward to know the physics that leads to these shapes.”

Essentially, the query they answered is what shapes are created when rocks break into items. Remarkably, they discovered that the core mathematical conjecture unites geological processes not solely on Earth however across the photo voltaic system as properly.

“Fragmentation is that this ubiquitous course of that’s grinding down planetary supplies,” Jerolmack says. “The photo voltaic system is suffering from ice and rocks which might be ceaselessly smashing aside. This work provides us a signature of that course of that we’ve by no means seen earlier than.”

Half of this understanding is that the elements that get away of a previously strong object should match collectively with none gaps, like a dropped dish on the verge of breaking. Because it seems, the one one of the so-called platonic types—polyhedra with sides of equal size—that match collectively with out gaps are cubes.

“One factor we’ve speculated in our group is that, fairly presumably Plato checked out a rock outcrop and after processing or analyzing the picture subconsciously in his thoughts, he conjectured that the typical form is one thing like a dice,” Jerolmack says.

“Plato was very delicate to geometry,” Domokos provides. Based on lore, the phrase “Let nobody ignorant of geometry enter” was engraved on the door to Plato’s Academy. “His intuitions, backed by his broad interested by science, could have led him to this concept about cubes,” says Domokos.

To check whether or not their mathematical fashions held true in nature, the workforce measured all kinds of rocks, a whole lot that they collected and 1000’s extra from beforehand collected datasets. Irrespective of whether or not the rocks had naturally weathered from a big outcropping or been dynamited out by people, the workforce discovered a great match to the cubic common.

Nevertheless, particular rock formations exist that seem to interrupt the cubic “rule.” The Large’s Causeway in Northern Eire, with its hovering vertical columns, is one instance, shaped by the bizarre course of of cooling basalt. These formations, although uncommon, are nonetheless encompassed by the workforce’s mathematical conception of fragmentation; they’re simply defined by out-of-the-ordinary processes at work.

“The world is a messy place,” says Jerolmack. “9 occasions out of 10, if a rock will get pulled aside or squeezed or sheared—and often these forces are occurring collectively—you find yourself with fragments that are, on common, cubic shapes. It’s solely you probably have a really particular stress situation that you simply get one thing else. The earth simply doesn’t do that typically.”

The fracture patterns the scientists recognized will be discovered not solely on Earth, however across the photo voltaic system, together with on the mosaic-like floor of Jupiter’s moon, Europa. Credit score: NASA/JPL-Caltech/SETI Institute

The researchers additionally explored fragmentation in two dimensions, or on skinny surfaces that perform as two-dimensional shapes, with a depth that’s considerably smaller than the width and size. There, the fracture patterns are completely different, although the central idea of splitting polygons and arriving at predictable common shapes nonetheless holds.

“It seems in two dimensions you’re about equally prone to get both a rectangle or a hexagon in nature,” Jerolmack says. “They’re not true hexagons, however they’re the statistical equal in a geometrical sense. You possibly can assume of it like paint cracking; a drive is performing to tug the paint aside equally from completely different sides, making a hexagonal form when it cracks.”

In nature, examples of these two-dimensional fracture patterns will be present in ice sheets, drying mud, and even the earth’s crust, the depth of which is way outstripped by its lateral extent, permitting it to perform as a de facto two-dimensional materials. It was beforehand recognized that the earth’s crust fractured on this manner, however the group’s observations assist the concept the fragmentation sample outcomes from plate tectonics.

Figuring out these patterns in rock could assist in predicting phenomenon similar to rock fall hazards or the chance and placement of fluid flows, similar to oil or water, in rocks. 

For the researchers, discovering what seems to be a elementary rule of nature rising from millennia-old insights has been an intense however satisfying expertise.

“There are rather a lot of sand grains, pebbles, and asteroids on the market, and all of them evolve by chipping in a common method,” says Domokos, who can also be co-inventor of the Gömböc, the primary recognized convex form with the minimal quantity—simply two—of static stability factors. Chipping by collisions progressively eliminates stability factors, however shapes cease quick of turning into a Gömböc; the latter seems as an unattainable finish level of this pure course of. 

The present outcome exhibits that the place to begin could also be a equally iconic geometric form: the dice with its 26 stability factors. “The truth that pure geometry gives these brackets for a ubiquitous pure course of, provides me happiness,” he says.

“Whenever you choose up a rock in nature, it’s not an ideal dice, however every one is a sort of statistical shadow of a dice,” provides Jerolmack. “It calls to thoughts Plato’s allegory of the cave. He posited an idealized type that was important for understanding the universe, however all we see are distorted shadows of that good type.”


Reference: “Plato’s dice and the pure geometry of fragmentation” by Gábor Domokos, Douglas J. Jerolmack, Ferenc Kun and János Török, 17 July 2020, Proceedings of the Nationwide Academy of Sciences.

Douglas Jerolmack is a professor within the Division of Earth and Environmental Science within the Faculty of Arts & Sciences and within the Division of Mechanical Engineering and Utilized Mechanics within the Faculty of Engineering and Utilized Science on the College of Pennsylvania.

Gábor Domokos is a professor and director of the MTA-BME Morphodynamics Analysis Group on the Budapest College of Know-how and Economics.

Ferenc Kun is a professor within the Division of Theoretical Physics on the College of Debrecen.

János Török is an affiliate professor within the Division of Theoretical Physics on the Budapest College of Know-how and Economics.
Back to top button