Tesla’s Patent Giveaway Fuels Electric Car Enthusiasm

Tesla Motors CEO Elon Musk threw the automotive trade right into a tizzy final week, when he introduced that he was throwing open the corporate’s patents.

Related Articles

Tesla’s Patent Giveaway Fuels Electric Car Enthusiasm

Some hailed the transfer as but extra proof of the abysmal state of the US patent system; others opined that it could give the electrical automobile trade a lift; others simply penned paeans of reward to Musk.

However — and there may be all the time a however — there have been cynical reactions as nicely, with some stating that Musk’s said aversion to patents meant some key applied sciences won’t be within the paperwork he provided to the auto trade, and others suggesting that Musk was being self-serving relatively than altruistic.

Flurry of Reactions

Musk introduced his intentions on Tesla’s weblog, garnering greater than 400 responses. most of which have been constructive. Take, for instance, that of mrwelsh: “As a stockholder and a Mannequin S proprietor, however largely as a short lived resident of a threatened planet, I extremely approve and am cautiously optimistic that this transfer will speed up the reason for electrifying transportation.”

Nonetheless, Robert Fahey was considerably skeptical: “This can be a uncommon state of affairs the place rivals can do a lot better in the event that they share know-how and reap the benefits of shared expertise and shopping for energy,” he wrote. “However this begs an enormous query: If Tesla is supply-constrained proper right down to the batteries, and wishes a brand new manufacturing unit simply to maintain its head afloat, how may any rival leapfrog Tesla even when it has the blueprints to take action? The place would it not get the products?”

Fahey did not see “any important change to the automotive panorama coming anytime quickly, patents or no patents.” However he did “see one more PR enhance for Tesla right here.”

The State of the Electric Car Trade

The marketplace for electrical automobiles is small; Tesla produced 7,353 Mannequin S automobiles in Q1 for the worldwide market.

The primary points holding down demand are customers’ lack of know-how, the necessity to undergo auto sellers, an insufficient infrastructure for charging electrical automobiles, and excessive manufacturing prices — though they’ve dropped sharply over time.

Though automakers plan to construct a community of charging amenities all through the U.S., Tesla solely inaugurated its one centesimal supercharging station in April.

“Musk … is aware of his efforts will seemingly fail if he cannot get extra corporations engaged on batteries and quick charger enhancements,” Rob Enderle, principal analyst on the Enderle Group, instructed LinuxInsider.

Nissan and BMW reportedly are serious about Tesla’s know-how.

An trade commonplace for charging stations can be helpful, and Musk “simply needs to verify there is not a competing commonplace that is available in and crushes them, so in that manner opening up his patents helps Tesla as a lot as something,” Daniel Castro, senior analyst on the
Information Technology & Innovation Foundation, instructed LinuxInsider.

Serving to Reform the US Patent System

Patents as of late “serve merely to stifle progress, entrench the positions of large companies, and enrich these within the authorized career relatively than the precise inventors,” Musk stated.

“When some of the progressive corporations within the nation criticizes the patent system, it’s clear the system is not working because it ought to,” Daniel Nazer, a employees lawyer on the Electronic Frontier Foundation, instructed LinuxInsider.

Musk’s transfer “ought to present some additional assist for reform [but] with legislative reform stalled within the Senate, we’ll want many corporations and people to push for reform,” Nazer stated.

Congress has been holding hearings on patent reform for a number of months, and plenty of payments on the problem have been launched in each chambers.

They embrace H.R. 3309, the Innovation Act; the Patent Abuse Discount Act of 2013; the Patent Litigation Integrity Act of 2013; and S. 1720 — the Patent Transparency and Enhancements Act of 2013.
Tesla's Patent Giveaway Fuels Electric Car Enthusiasm

Back to top button